The story
Amor Arenal opened in 2018 on a stretch of Route 142 between La Fortuna and the national park, on the lip of a forested canyon that nobody had built on. The casitas are made of tropical hardwoods and set along the canyon edge so that every terrace looks straight down the ravine to the volcano; each has a warm mineral-spring plunge pool, a double rain shower, a king bed with fine linen, a 55-inch television, air conditioning and a stocked complimentary minibar.
It is smaller and quieter than the Nayara estate — three mineral-fed pools, one restaurant, a spa of three treatment rooms surrounded by vegetation, an open-air yoga studio, guided trails, and sloths and toucans on the property. El Rancho serves seasonal, local, largely organic menus; guests write about the Korean BBQ night and the chef's wine pairings. A perfect 5.0 across more than 1,500 reviews puts it, with Nayara Springs, at the top of the country.